Are Composite Photos “Cheating”?
... especially if you use AI to speed up the process.
Caveat up front: I’ll always tell you if an image I share used any AI (other than standard tools included in Lightroom such as noise reduction, masking, and spot removal). If I don’t specify that AI was used, you can safely assume the picture is 100% my own work.
I Love the final version of this picture of a Coppery-Tailed (aka Elegant) Trogon.
It is based on images that I captured myself. But this is not exactly (although maybe 90%) what the scene looked like in the camera, or through my view finder at the time I clicked the shutter button.
It all started yesterday afternoon when I watched a video that Tony Baldasaro included at the end of his latest “Inside the Frame” post.
Oh man, I wanted to go back into my archive to try some of these Lightroom techniques on a few of the thousands of bird photos I’ve taken over the years. I found the folder from the first time I’d photographed an Elegant Trogon.
Scrolling through, I came across an image that I skipped over the first time because it was very soft, and maybe a little over exposed (oh yea, and the bird was looking away). But I loved the scene itself, especially the background.
So I played around with it a little bit myself in Lightroom, mainly as a way to practice employing some of Tony’s tricks. This was the initial result:
Pretty cool, but obviously still not a “keeper”
Then this morning, I thought to myself:
“Hmmm, I wonder what Gemini could do with this if I give it a reference photo with the bird’s head turned and the beak showing?”
So that’s what I did …
Ok, not bad. But what if I ask it to “sharpen the bird and branch but leave the blurred background”. And boom, we end up with the image at the top of the page. But was this too much cheating?
Here’s my personal AI “rule”:
If I’m using my own photographs, and it’s something I could have done myself, but AI can do it much quicker (and possibly slightly better), then I’m okay with using the AI.
Now I’m not an expert at composite photos, but I’ve done a few.
Could I have taken the head of a bird from one of my own photos, stitched it onto this image, then blended, enhanced, and sharpened everything to produce that final picture?
Maybe, quite possibly.
But it probably would have taken me days, weeks, or maybe even months of putting it away, then coming back (and using different software tools), to finally get it perfect; or at least good enough to share.
My entire interaction with Gemini lasted just over a minute.
The whole process involved my ideas, my photos, and my vision of what the final picture would look like. Is it okay to still call this my own “art”?
Today’s Picture of the Day (taken Tuesday afternoon) is definitely not a composite, and Gemini was not consulted when I edited it. 😎
Til Next time,

Memories:
(A look back at post from around this time a year ago):









Discussion about this post